CONSULTATIVE GROUP MEETING for CAMBODIA
Phnom Penh, 20 June 2002

Session 1:
Pro-Poor Macro-Economic Management and Fiscal Performance
 

Introduction

by

Mr. KEAT CHHON, MP

Senior Minister, Minister of Economy and Finance,

Vice-Chairman, Council for the Development of Cambodia

Royal Government of Cambodia

 
   

Your Excellency, Mr. Chairman;
Your Excellencies, Distinguished Representatives of Donor Countries,
Your Excellencies, Representatives of International Organizations,
Your Excellencies, Members of the Royal Government of Cambodia,
Ladies and Gentlemen:

Good morning to all of you!

Today is it my great pleasure to provide all of you, participating in this important meeting the overview of current macroeconomic status and fiscal performance of Cambodia. I am certain that you will appreciate how far and positive the developments have been, and also how these have contributed to sustainable, pro-poor growth.

The year 2002 has been decisive in the implementation of the development agenda of Cambodia. This year is witness to the intensified implementation of wide-ranging reforms in economic and social governance by the Royal Government of Cambodia. Peace and security has been further consolidated and reforms broadened through all key sectors: fiscal management, banking, public administration and the role of the military.

Looking beyond this year to 2003 and onwards, we should see the further strengthening of the foundations for Cambodia’s broad-based, sustainable development. Such is the result of our economic and financial policies that continue to sustain economic growth, reduce poverty, accelerate economic reconstruction, maintain macroeconomic stability, undertake fiscal reforms and strengthen banking and financial institutions.

Substantial progress has been achieved in fiscal reforms since the Consultative Meeting of June 2001 in Tokyo. The Royal Government of Cambodia has rigorously applied policy measures that are pro-Democracy, pro-growth, pro-private sector, pro-poor and pro-environment. Such rigor has been in full consistency with the Royal Government’s development platform.

As part of the reforms, key fiscal policy measures have been enacted as follows: (a) revenue enhancement via improved tax and duty collection, strengthened governance and suppression of smuggling; (b) sound management of state-owned assets; and (c) increased social and economic spending. These thrusts have resulted in the maintenance of macro-economic stability and promoted broad-based, sustainable development and poverty alleviation.

Our policies and strategies for pro-poor macroeconomic management have been articulated in the following strategic statements:

First, the Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (IPRSP);

Second, the Second Five-Year Socio-Economic Development Plan: 2001-2005 (SEDP II);

Third, the Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP); and

Fourth, the Financial Sector Blueprint for 2001-2010.

Furthermore, the Position Papers prepared by the Royal Government of Cambodia for this CG Meeting is consistent with these key strategic statements;

Taken together, the strategic statements and policy papers set out the Royal Government’s consolidated strategy for national development covering: (i) the establishment of the rule of law, (ii) economic stabilization and structural reforms, (iii) capacity building, (iv) rehabilitation and construction of physical infrastructure and facilities, (v) rapid rural development, (vi) sound environmental and natural resources management and (vii) the integration of the Cambodian economy into the region and the world.

I urge our partners and friends at this CG meeting to carefully study these strategic documents and policy papers.

Sustaining the Momentum of Economic and Fiscal Reforms

Ladies and gentlemen, the RGC has rigorously implemented the policy measures proposed during the June 2001 CG Meeting held in Tokyo.

Fiscal reform has been the cornerstone of our actions in 200 1-2002. As part of the Technical Cooperation Assistance Project (TCAP), substantial action has been sustained on improvement of customs and tax administration. Beginning in late 2001, attention has also been focused at key implementation issues, including: (i) review of the contract on the sale of tickets to the Angkor temple complex; (ii) establishment of a task force comprising the MEF and line ministries to inventory state assets, monitor leases of state assets and collection of arrears and payments due on such leases, and (iii) actions to increase revenues from Posts and Telecommunications.

Moreover, several structural measures have been implemented to strengthen tax and customs administration: (i) establishment and meeting of the Steering Committee for PSI; (ii) transfer of all government bank accounts to the National Bank of Cambodia; (iii) improved coordination between the Customs and Tax Departments; (iv) establishment of the Large Taxpayers Unit (LTU); (v) ensuring the monitoring and collection of tax arrears from the largest taxpayers; (vi) strengthening the anti-smuggling unit of the Customs Department and establishing anti-smuggling cooperation arrangements with the Armed Forces and the Police; (vii) establishing the Cash Management Committee; (viii) adoption by the Cabinet of the Amended Law on Investment; (ix) implementation of procurement procedures for the four key ministries (Health, Education, Agriculture and Rural Development); and (x) operationalizing the National Audit Authority (NAA).

However, we recognize that additional measures should be taken to improve fiscal management. Increased expenditures in 2000 and 2001 for flood relief still has an impact on the cash flow and the commune council election spending further constrained budget execution. Nevertheless, a positive highlight of expenditures in early 2002 was the implementation of civil service restructuring. It is our conviction that increased salaries for civil servants commensurate with their responsibilities, especially for teachers and health workers, is indeed “social spending with a human dimension”. This is crucial for institutional capacity building and ultimately will have positive impact on economic performance.

Robust Macroeconomic and Fiscal Performance

As the result of the implementation of the reform programs mentioned earlier, Cambodia has achieved remarkable macroeconomic and fiscal performance. As the Prime Minister has already announced, the National Institute of Statistics, Ministry of Planning, with technical assistance of the ADB, has updated the macroeconomic performance figures for Cambodia. We are proud to report that the Cambodian economy continued its strong growth of 6.9 percent in 1999, 7.7 percent in 2000 and 6.3 percent in 2001. This remarkable performance has been due to continued robust growth in garments manufacturing and tourism. Textiles, clothing and footwear manufacturing posted a 26.8 percent growth in 2001, following the increase of 40.6 percent in 2000.

Encouraged by the gains of recent years and the overall improvements in the world economy, the Ministry of Economy and Finance has revised its macroeconomic outlook for 2002 - upwards. The revised macroeconomic framework for 2002 indicates that GDP is expected to grow by 5.5 percent, higher than the 5 percent previously projected. The higher economic growth is anticipated from the exports of garments and the vibrant tourism sector.

Overall, Cambodia has achieved macroeconomic stability, with annual GDP growth during 1999-2001 averaging 7 percent, very low inflation and a stable exchange rate. Such performance is indeed consistent with the target of 6-7 percent annual growth set by the Prime Minister in the Second Social and Economic Development Plan.

The fiscal performance of the Royal Government in the first quarter of 2002 has been good, revenue mobilization improved and expenditures restrained. Domestic revenue was 15 percent above the 2001 performance, boosted by non-tax revenue that increased by 55 percent compared to 2000. Tax revenues in the first quarter of 2002 were lower by 4 percent than in 2001 due to large recovery on arrears during the first quarter of 2001. Customs duties also fell by 17 percent following the reduction of tariff rates as part of our preparation for AFTA and WTO accession. However, excise taxes increased by 30 percent, following the increase in excise rates to compensate for tariff restructuring.

We have exercised maximum restraints on expenditures. The 2002 budget has been implemented with extreme prudence and caution to make room for priority spending: commune elections, civil service reform and the overhaul and construction of physical infrastructure. As a result, total public expenditure in the first quarter 2002 increased only one percent compared to 2001.

As projected in Cambodia’s 2002 Financial Law, the current budget surplus will be maintained at 1.5% of GDP, while the overall fiscal deficit (excluding grants) will be contained at less than 6% of GDP and financed by external, concessional resources and grants. The external current account deficit is projected to widen to -11%.

The Government’s prudent monetary policy and fiscal discipline have successfully maintained low inflation, a stable exchange rate and steady economic growth. Despite the shrinkage in the number of banks following the bank-restructuring program, money supply continued to expand at a reasonable pace. Liquidity of the banking sector recorded a robust growth of 9.2 percent in the first quarter of 2002 compared to December 2001, as the public’s preference for monetary assets persisted. The increase was mainly due to strong growth of foreign currency deposits, the largest component of broad money, which increased by 8.5 percent. Credit to the private sector rose by 6.7 percent during the period. Gross official reserves likewise grew by 7.5 percent, reflecting strong export performance, sustained tourist arrivals and other capital inflows.

In short, Cambodia has achieved significant progress in maintaining macroeconomic stability and promoting high performance of economic growth.

However, the much more should be done in order to move Cambodia to a new plateau of sustainable development. And one of the challenges facing Cambodia is to share the benefit of growth to alleviate poverty.

Sharing the Benefits of Growth

The development of Cambodia must not be limited to the cities. Thus we have embarked on decentralization and deconcentration to ensure that public services reach every single Cambodian child, woman and man in all parts of the country. A new commune budget system has been put into practice where during the first phase, the commune budget will consist of a block grant of 20 billion CRs transferred from the central budget.

Furthermore, the “New Social Policy Agenda” of Cambodia directs the pouring of massive proportions of the budget into the priority sectors of education, health, agriculture and rural development — the foundations of future growth, equity and progress. In fact, over the last five years we have more than tripled the budget disbursed for health and almost tripled the budget disbursed for education. As part of our Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF), we envisage to double the budget for health and education in the next three years.

Vision Beyond 2002

Looking beyond this year to 2003 and onwards, we should see the further strengthening of the foundations for Cambodia’s broad-based, sustainable development. Such is the result of our economic and financial policies that continue to sustain economic growth, reduce poverty, accelerate economic reconstruction, maintain macroeconomic stability, undertake fiscal reforms and strengthen banking and financial institutions.

Overall, the reduction in expenditures and the increase in revenue collection will improve the current balance and promote saving for investment for our ultimate objective of sustainable growth. Thus the framework for the 2003 budget is based on the following aggregates: domestic revenue of 131/4 percent of GDP, current expenditure of 11¾ percent of GDP and current budget surplus of 1.5 percent of GDP.   

Administrative spending will amount to 5.2 percent of GDP, social and economic spending at 3.8 percent of GDP, and military and security spending at 2.5 percent of GDP. Furthermore, over the next three years we will strive to double the budget for education and health. The Royal Government recognizes that any further efforts to increase the salaries of social sector workers should be consistent with the government policy and achievements in revenue mobilization.

Private Sector Development

The Royal Government of Cambodia is firmly committed to enabling the private sector to play its rightful role as the primary engine of economic growth. The government recognizes that the capabilities of the state agencies and offices should be directed toward creating the environment of policies and public goods that will release and encourage the rapid growth of private employment and enterprise.

The Government’s thrust in private sector development is embodied in the new Socio-Economic Development Plan 2001-2005, particularly in terms of the focus on: (i) building up of physical infrastructure, (ii) promotion of good governance especially the control of corruption and (iii) enactment of enterprise-friendly laws and investment regulations. Finally, priority is also focused on the enhancement of corporate governance through the strict enforcement of the Law on Corporate Accounting and Auditing.

Pro-Poor Macroeconomic Policies

The Royal Government of Cambodia realizes that its development policies and initiatives should be linked and coordinated within a comprehensive work plan so that these are effective for sustainable development. Thus we consider the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) as a useful mechanism to set out our development vision and translate policies and strategies into budget requirements. To this end, it is important to have short- and long-term indicators and targets for monitoring the effectiveness and outcomes of public policies. The Fiscal Reform Working Group and the Social Sector Working Group have worked out indicators and benchmarks to this effect. The Government has also entered into partnership with the Asian Development Bank in the context of the Poverty Reduction Partnership Agreement (PRPA), as a complementary mechanism for the assessment of progress in development efforts. The indicators employed in these exercises will be incorporated in the proposed Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF).

Corollary to effective monitoring and assessment, it is important to coordinate data collection efforts and promote policy research. The Ministry of Economy and Finance intends to establish a resource center to collect all studies, working papers, surveys and data that will help enable the government to make informed policy decisions, and help build the government’s capacity and technical expertise in order to achieve reforms. We therefore ask the donors and the international community to assist in this effort by providing research materials, access to research and analysis and providing direct technical support. In particular, we urge the donor community to shift away from traditional technical assistance towards support directed at strengthening the government’s internal capacity building efforts.

As part of the PRSP exercise, the MEF will conduct the following studies:

 
An analysis of employment and the labor market;
An assessment of the incidence of education and health expenditures, updating the 1997 PER;
A tracking study to ensure that projected increases in health and education spending actually reach schools and 
clinics;
A study to develop alternative formulae for budget allocation to commune councils consistent with 
poverty-reduction objectives;
Analysis leading to the consolidation of budgets, including external funds, for four priority sectors; education, 
health, roads, water and sanitation;
Costing of all major programs to ensure consistency with the macroeconomic framework; and
Target-Setting for outcomes and intermediate indicators based on sectoral inputs and results of consultations with 
stakeholders, reviewed on a regular basis.
 

In the context of the PRSP, the Millennium Development Goals should be translated into budgetary requirements, the work to be done and investments required. Included in such programming are the interventions that determine child and maternal health, and the status of nutrition and school enrollment. Indeed, it is important to have a permanent mechanism for monitoring the outcomes.

Indeed, much more remains to be done to develop a good PRSP. We also need to formulate an industrialization strategy that goes beyond the garments industry, such as the development of agro-industry, commerce and tourism. We should also consider the various forms and options for social safety nets that are appropriate for Cambodia to help the vulnerable groups to weather external and domestic shocks. We should strive to ensure that economic integration and trade liberalization work for everyone. Finally, it is important to translate policies and strategies into implementation. Therefore the Ministries shall include in their sectoral strategies, concrete, phased and time-bound action plans and projects so that the poverty reduction strategies do not remain only on paper.

Conclusion

Your Excellencies, Ladies and Gentlemen,

I expect that our discussions during this CG meeting will not only be informative but intensive as well. We welcome all viewpoints and suggestions on how we can meet the challenges that lie in the path of Cambodia in implementing a pro-poor, sustainable development strategy and policy. The Royal Government welcomes concrete and pro-active proposals from all quarters to help improve the efficiency of our strategies. All together we can make constructive contributions to the shaping of a better future for Cambodia and its people.

Thank you for your kind attention!

 

Home | 6th CG Meeting | Agenda | Contents| List of Participants | Position Paper | DCR | Partnership | Government | Donors | Download | Map | Photo